Wilmington Underground
heart and soul of our Wilmington community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Wilmington Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

does God punish people?

who's talking here?

G-Momma 2
Nemesis:o) 1
Nani 3
Linda Bell 1
AmyF 1
Aunt Ruby 1
sk 2
~Melissa~ 1
PAULA 1
FiftyAndFit 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Nani --- 17 years ago -

im sitting here just wondering, does God really punish people? are there signs or little clues that tell you you're about to really get it? i was raised catholic so i was always taught that yes, he will punish the heck outta you. but does he or would he really? 

G-Momma --- 17 years ago -

Well....if you look at Job, God allowed satan to mess him up bad. Job lost his wives, children, land and live-stock. But Satan did it to him---not God. However----the discussion between Satan and God went along the lines of Satan saying Job would toss God aside if he lost all and God said Job wouldn't do that. So God allowed Job to be put to the test. Job stood fast and God gave him more in the end than he had in the beginning. Hope that helps. 

G-Momma --- 17 years ago -

Then there is John the Baptist....the man lost his head! (chopped off) Could God have stepped in and stopped it?---you bet. And of course Jesus....awful painful death at the hand of wicked evil people. While God doesn't "do" these things to us, he allows them to happen and all those circumstances came to glorify God's desires in the end. 

Nani --- 17 years ago -

but these are both examples regarding faith being tested. my question is, does God intentionally punish you while on this earth, i guess if you know you're doing something wrong? like say, this dude hit a handicapped person and for some ironic reason, he ends up handicapped as well. would you say that irony was God' way of punishing the dude? 

Nemesis:o) --- 17 years ago -

Hell Yeah he does....just ask Stu. 

FiftyAndFit --- 17 years ago -

I believe in karma. I also believe in Jesus. I just differ on some doctrinal issues with others. If I do evil to someone I think it will come back to me. The same for good. I think that if you do good to others it will come back to you as good. Please know that doing good does not mean the same thing as being nice. Doing good could come in the form of warning a boss that the way he is treating you or others is wrong. I have had that experience. In warning someone like a mean boss you may be doing them a favor. After all you ARE saving them from bad karma if they are treating others in an undignified way. That karma could very well take a bite out of their rear end. As far as God punishing people, no I do not believe so. I believe He disciplines those He loves. Discipline is not the same thing as punishment. Somewhere, I think in Hebrews, it states that He disciplines those that He loves . No discipline seems pleasant at the time but afterward produces a harvest of righteousness by those that have been trained by it. Somewhere in Hebrews that is written. Maybe chapter 12? Not sure. 

PAULA --- 17 years ago -

I lean toward what Steve is saying. God is love, so much so that he gave us his son as sacrifice, and should we accept, our sins are forgiven with a heartfelt repentance. He already knows everything we are going to do, say and think, and in spite of that, His love doesnt change. It's us. We have the freedom to choose or not. He gave us Hiswords to follow, our choice. That man that raped that little girl, God loves, He doesnt love the sin, He hates that sin, He loves the sinner and will gently coax us toward His truth. However, it is all in His word, messages to live by, and in it is says Be not deceived, God is not mocked, for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap. So its our choice what we sow, what we do, and we must remember that many carry the title, and man looks on the outward appearnce, but God sees the heart. I do believe he disciplines us, all in effort to mold us into the love "Jesus" but often things we walk through are things we are reaping. 

Linda Bell --- 17 years ago -

Nani, That is a hard question. We can always find things to question and wonder why. Here is how I feel about it. But in no way do I think my feelings on this is the way everyone should feel, just the way I feel. I believe that God does not punish people. I believe that the choice a person makes is up to that person, he eithers follows God's Word or he follows Satan. I also believe that if something bads happens to us that God is not punishing us. I firmly believe that things happen for a reason, good and bad, and that God wants us to take something good out of everything, even the bad. The are so many things that can happen in a person's life and we ask the question "Why God". I know for myself that I have questioned God on things happening in my life, but as I grow to Love God more I know it was not something I should have questioned, but should have found a good in it. I know that as humans it is sometimes hard for us not to question God, but I think rather than question God we should pray to God and ask Him to guide us in the path that He has for us. I also believe that we should be thankful for everything. Maybe the event itself is bad, but there is always something in every event that we can find to say "Thank You God" for, and it may take us some time to see it and we may never see it, but it is there. I believe that God will give us His Reward. 

AmyF --- 17 years ago -

My question is this: Do you feel like you are being punished? Or are you punishing yourself? 

Nani --- 17 years ago -

im not punishing myself, but dammit, why did i have to catch this cold and sound like darth vader? i mean just after i made fun of my sister? im telling you, its gotta be God punishing me for making fun of her! lol 

~Melissa~ --- 17 years ago -

Husky voices are sexy Nano! =) 

sk --- 17 years ago -

my question is, does God intentionally punish you while on this earth SHORT ANSWER....THINK Sodom and Gomorrah!! Gen 18:20 THROUGH Gen 19:29 LONG ANSWER LATER PLEASE EXCUSE CAPS.... 

sk --- 17 years ago -

LONG ANSWER im sitting here just wondering, does God really punish people? are there signs or little clues that tell you you're about to really get it? i was raised catholic so i was always taught that yes, he will punish the heck outta you. but does he or would he really? Gen 18:20 SodomH5467 and GomorrahH6017 Gen 18:20 And the LORDH3068 said,H559 BecauseH3588 the cryH2201 of SodomH5467 and GomorrahH6017 is great,H7231 and becauseH3588 their sinH2403 is veryH3966 grievous;H3513 Gen 18:21 I will go downH3381 now,H4994 and seeH7200 whether they have doneH6213 altogetherH3617 according to the cryH6818 of it, which is comeH935 untoH413 me; and ifH518 not,H3808 I will know.H3045 Gen 19:11 And they smoteH5221 the menH376 thatH834 were at the doorH6607 of the houseH1004 with blindness,H5575 both smallH4480 H6996 and great:H1419 so that they wearied themselvesH3811 to findH4672 the door.H6607 Gen 19:13 ForH3588 weH587 will destroyH7843 (H853) thisH2088 place,H4725 becauseH3588 the cryH6818 of them is waxen greatH1431 (H853) before the faceH6440 of the LORD;H3068 and the LORDH3068 hath sentH7971 us to destroyH7843 it. Gen 19:23 The sunH8121 was risenH3318 uponH5921 the earthH776 when LotH3876 enteredH935 into Zoar.H6820 Gen 19:24 Then the LORDH3068 rainedH4305 uponH5921 SodomH5467 and uponH5921 GomorrahH6017 brimstoneH1614 and fireH784 fromH4480 H854 the LORDH3068 out ofH4480 heaven;H8064 Gen 19:25 And he overthrewH2015 (H853) thoseH411 cities,H5892 and allH3605 the plain,H3603 and allH3605 the inhabitantsH3427 of the cities,H5892 and that which grewH6780 upon the ground.H127 Gen 19:27 And AbrahamH85 gat up earlyH7925 in the morningH1242 toH413 the placeH4725 whereH834 H8033 he stoodH5975 (H853) beforeH6440 the LORD:H3068 Gen 19:28 And he lookedH8259 towardH5921 H6440 SodomH5467 and Gomorrah,H6017 and towardH5921 H6440 allH3605 the landH776 of the plain,H3603 and beheld,H7200 and, lo,H2009 the smokeH7008 of the countryH776 went upH5927 as the smokeH7008 of a furnace.H3536 Gen 19:29 And it came to pass,H1961 when GodH430 destroyedH7843 (H853) the citiesH5892 of the plain,H3603 that GodH430 rememberedH2142 (H853) Abraham,H85 and sentH7971 (H853) LotH3876 out of the midstH4480 H8432 of the overthrow,H2018 when he overthrewH2015 (H853) the citiesH5892 in the whichH2004 H834 LotH3876 dwelt.H3427 EXCUSE CAPS PLEASE :-/ 

Aunt Ruby --- 17 years ago -

im telling you, its gotta be God punishing me for making fun of her! lol You caught your sisters germ, that's all! I believe God is extremely busy and doesn't have the desire or time to reach out making sure this one and that one catches a cold. Hope you get well soon :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Wilmington Underground