Wilmington Underground
heart and soul of our Wilmington community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Wilmington Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

What would YOU do?

who's talking here?

oceanbreeze 1
Nani 1
Linda Bell 2
~♥ twinkle toes ♥~ 1
~Melissa~ 1
CommunicationIsKey 2
Tiffany 2
Carmen 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CommunicationIsKey --- 17 years ago -

My husband and I have families that are conservative with the gift giving (Christmas and birthdays) and that's the way we like it. The adults rarely trade gifts, just cards and good wishes on special days. Maybe we'll go out to eat together but that's rare since most of us live in separate corners of the country. The exception to this concerns the kids in the family. There are only 4 total: My husband and I have two young boys and my husband's sister also has two boys. To keep things fun we've always sent gifts for them at Christmas and on their birthdays and they've done likewise for our boys. Now here's what I need advice on: My sister-in-law's oldest child is now in his first year of college, age 18 (the other is only 13). I think it's time we "cut him loose" in terms of the gift-giving. It's time he joined the ranks of we adults where he'll just get a card and warm wishes like the rest of us. BUT...It doesn't feel right to imagine how the boys will be sitting side by side at Christmas with only the younger sibling getting a gift. What would you do? Do we continue giving gifts until both are 18? That's my best guess. 

~♥ twinkle toes ♥~ --- 17 years ago -

I'd do a gift card. just make sure its not to a store that is closing! lol It hasn't really been "discussed" between you and the other parents to change anything so, it wouldn't be right to just stop now out of the blue. That is just what I think....maybe you could enclose a letter saying in a nice way that this gift will help you get on your feet in the "real world" and how he's an adult now.....or something like that 

~Melissa~ --- 17 years ago -

We cut them off at 16! We have a big family and cannot afford to give give give. So, just the little ones get a gift and when they reach the ages of 16 I usually give like cookies or something that the other adults will get. I usually make a tin of goodies for each family and the teens get their own. That way no one is left out. 

Carmen --- 17 years ago -

I had this same problem a couple of years back, We have some cousins that range from about 16-19 and I couldnt NOT get them something so i just got them a big bag of variety candy from Sams, it worked out pretty good. They were happy and so was I cause I only spent about $4 on each bag of candy versus spending atleast $20 per child-and there were 4 so it added up fast. I put the candy in gift bags- so they were still surprised and they loved it. 

Linda Bell --- 17 years ago -

I would not think of him as an adult in the way that I think of me as an adult. Since he has gone on to college I would think of him as a young person heading toward being adult. Since he is at college and I would assume his needs has change, why not do a gift of "needs" in a container that he can reuse. Our neighbors, kids and I have always exchanged small gifts and then of course grandkids got included. So now just my neighbor and I exchange gifts and then just give to the grandkids. Last year I made them gift bags of goodies, cookies, brownies, breads that I cooked and some store brought stuff like candy and drink mixes. I think they enjoyed this better than anything else I have given them. The youngest told me that the cookies were so good that he would not even share with Santa, that made me laugh. My Christmas List of gifts to buy has gone down over the years, so I don't have a lot of people to buy gifts for. But I do have people I like to remember, so I bake a number of different cookies and make a bag for each with a Christmas Card. I am hoping that I can afford to buy the baking needs this year. I have already starting buying what's on sale. So hopefully by time to bake the stuff I will have everything I need. Hope you come up with something that is great in your situation. I know sometimes these things can be stressful. 

Linda Bell --- 17 years ago -

I just thought of something else I do. I always buy an extra Attractions Dining Coupon book. I will send a coupon out of it with a Christmas Card to some friends. I spend $25 for the book, but get many gifts out of it, plus use some them myself. I try to give my friends something out of it I know they use. Like this year they have the Michael's coupon in it so I will give that to someone who likes to buy there. I would love to get 40% off a item myself. So if there is something like that you can invest in and use that might be some thing you can do also. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

an extra Attractions Dining Coupon book lol!! That is what our family is getting! lol lol In my family, we don;t cut anyone out due to age, but we are crazy like that. but....I agree with families doing it..it is a good idea. That said....he JUST started college, give him something that is more "grown up" like the coupon book. Something he can use to help him save money. then, talk to his mother and let her know that this may be the last year he is on the KIDS'S Christmas list. :o) 

Carmen --- 17 years ago -

i can still remember sitting at the "kids table" lol IT actually hasnt been that long ago we got bumped up. We are still not at the "adult table" but somewhere inbetween. 

Tiffany --- 17 years ago -

i can still remember sitting at the "kids table" lol IT actually hasnt been that long ago we got bumped up. We are still not at the "adult table" but somewhere inbetween. LOL!!!! well, out kids table really are KIDS tables! lol lol you know....the little card tables with the little fold upi chairs! lol lol I have a few family memebers that need to sit at the kids table FOR LIFE!! better yet.....I'm just hoping they don;t come this year! ha ha ha 

oceanbreeze --- 17 years ago -

oo yea the kid's table ..I remember that.. my daughter is 18 and just started college this year to..she does not 'expect' gifts though..she would rather 'give' than to 'get'..so when they reach 18 they are an 'adult' or want to be treated like one in my opinion..and if they have any clue about our economy right now -then they should not expect anything from anybody.. not to be 'mean' but- I say cut the 'umbilical cord' so to speak at the age of 18 in matters of 'gifts at the holidays' especially if they are NOT your kids..LOL.. 

Nani --- 17 years ago -

18 is old enough, give him the boot, just tell him that he is now an adult, welcome to the wonderful world of grown ups, buy your own sh!t. half the time they dont use what you give them anyways. or you could do a best buy giftcard for like 20 bucks or so, they never fail to please :) 

CommunicationIsKey --- 17 years ago -

Thanks so much for all of you that took the time to post your opinion and experiences! One thing I didn't explain when I originally posed my dilemma is the method by which we've given the gifts for the two nephews all these years. Because they've always lived so far away (currently in Washington state), we've just sent money to my husband's sister and have her buy the boys' birthday presents on our behalf. When it came time for Xmas presents for our boys and theirs, we parents didn't even bother to exchange money since they have two boys just like us. We just bought toys for our own kids (since we know what they like best) and signed the uncle's and aunt's name to them. It was an even trade of sorts. There's no sense sending toys clear across the country (and pay shipping) when they can be purchased locally. Anyway, I think I'm going to just cut him off. Haha. He's a fantastic young man now (valedictorian of his class) so he's mature and will understand. We will send a homemade card (I like to make them on the computer) with a note of explanation and congratulation for joining us "on the other side." And I will run it all by his mom (my SIL) and make sure she's cool with the plans. Again, many thanks for your insights! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Wilmington Underground