Wilmington Underground
heart and soul of our Wilmington community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Wilmington Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Ice Cream Cakes!

who's talking here?

babydollautumn 2
Fuzzy Black Cat 1
Nemesis:o) 1
Linda Bell 1
poosh 2
~Melissa~ 10
*KB* 2
Cioccolata 2
Kelmist 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

My husbands b-day is tomorrow and I want to make him a ice cream cake! Does anyone know how to make one?? And Yes I could just go out and buy one but I make all of my cakes and it would be wrong for me to just go to Walmart and pick just a random cake up............ 

Linda Bell --- 19 years ago -

The ice cream store, Cold Stone or Stone Cold (I can not never remember which way it goes) has ice cream cakes and they are so good. You could check to see what they offer as I have no clue. But if no one comes up with a recipe for you it would be something to look at. 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

Thanks Linda... I better figure out what to do soon! lol Time is running out! 

Kelmist --- 19 years ago -

I don't have a recipe, but I remember someone telling me once how it was done.... First bake the cake and freeze it. Take your ice cream and let it thaw just enough that you can mold it a bit. Put it on the frozen cake and freeze. When all of it is frozen together, trim the edges to "neaten" it up. Freeze it all again and then frost the frozen cake and put it all back in the freezer. I've never done it, but it sounds like it would work. Of course, I'm not sure if you want to experiment on such an important cake and my "recipe" is just what I remember someone telling me! Good Luck! 

poosh --- 19 years ago -

Make the Duggar family recipe one,lol LAYERED ICE CREAM CAKE Makes a 9”x 13” Pan 24 Ice cream sandwiches 8 oz. Cool Whip™ 1 Hershey’s™ chocolate syrup bottle 1 Smuckers™ caramel syrup bottle 2 king size Butterfinger™ candy bars chopped up 1st layer -12 ice cream sandwiches 2nd – half of whipped cream 3rd - half of Butterfinger™ bars, Squeeze 1/2 of caramel & chocolate over that. 4th - rest of ice cream sandwiches 5th – Cool Whip™ 6th - rest of Butterfinger™, caramel & chocolate You can freeze this and eat as desired! Yummy! Yummy! 

Kelmist --- 19 years ago -

Oops...I think I put an extra "freeze" in there! After you trim the edges (very sharp knife) you should be able to frost it right away....THEN freeze it all! 

Kelmist --- 19 years ago -

poosh....it's only a little after 8 in the morning and you are making me want butterfingers....NOW!!!!! Sounds Yummy! 

poosh --- 19 years ago -

LOL...I had an icecream sandwich already! 

*KB* --- 19 years ago -

Male suggestion here,.. Be creative, outside of the norm is what we want,..I personally would LOVE any ice cream cake that my wife made with her own hands and a pair of freshly worn eatable panties on top with a split cherry, stream of cream(whipped,..oh yeah, whip it) and my name anywhere on there! (yum) 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

Thanks for the recipes and suggestions... Think I will experiment! Poosh yours sounds heavenly.. And KB that stuff is for later in the evening but the party cake will have to be a bit cleaned up because children are going to be attending... lol 

*KB* --- 19 years ago -

they have to learn sometime! Better from the parents! 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

If I learned from my parents... well let me go I feel sick!! lol... 

babydollautumn --- 19 years ago -

I have a really easy one using ice cream sandwiches. If you want it just let me know. 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

Sure give it to me BDA! All suggestions and recipes are very much appreciated!! 

babydollautumn --- 19 years ago -

1 cup oreos (about 10) 1/2 cup milk 1 pkg (3.9 oz) chocolate instant pudding and pie filling 12 oz cool whip thawed 12 frozen ice cream sandwiches (3.75 oz each) 2 tblsp semi-sweet choc morsels OR multicolored sprinkles Coarsely chop cookies. Combine milk and pudding until mixture is smooth and begins to thicken. Immediately fold in HALF of the whip topping and cookies. Set aside Working quickly, arrange 6 of the ice cream sandwiches side by side on a large platter. Spread filling evenly over sandwiches. Top with remaining ice cream sandwiches, forming a rectangular torte; smooth sides. Spread remaining whipped topping over tops and sides. Grate chocolate morsels over top. Freeze at least 30 minutes or until ready to serve. 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

Thanks BDA! That sounds great... If I don't use this one for the birthday it is definitely something I will be making soon! And I like it because it sounds so simple! 

Fuzzy Black Cat --- 19 years ago -

I usually browse Allrecipes.com for my recipe needs. It has GREAT recipes and ideas and many of them have reviews! 

Kelmist --- 19 years ago -

Okay...I got curious and started looking around. I found this for a more traditional Ice Cream Cake that is different from what I posted...and it makes sense. Choose your flavor of ice cream. About 24 hours before serving, take the ice cream out of the freezer and allow to thaw for about 30 minutes. You want it soft, but not too soft. You don't want it runny. Line one of the round cake pans with plastic wrap. Work as quickly as you can, since you don't want it to melt too much. Start with the bottom of the pan, making sure the ice cream gets into the corners. Try to get it as even as possible, being careful to fill in any holes and gaps. Cover with plastic wrap, then with foil, and place into the freezer overnight to re-harden. In the morning, bake your cake. Fill the other round cake pan with half the batter, and fill the cupcake tin with the other half (save these for kids' lunch boxes). Bake, cool, and remove from pan as directed on box or in recipe. It is important that the cake is completely cool before proceeding. About 3 hours (or more) before serving time, remove the cake pan with the ice cream from the freezer. Remove top plastic and foil, then place a dinner plate on top of the pan, and invert the pan onto the plate. Remove the plastic wrap from the ice cream. Working quickly, place the cooled cake on top of the ice cream. Frost and decorate. Cover with plastic wrap and place back into freezer to harden for about three hours or more. At serving time, remove from freezer, decorate with candles, sing Happy Birthday, and cut as you would a store-bought cake. 

Cioccolata --- 19 years ago -

I would just buy ice cream cake, since we don't have freezer space. 

Nemesis:o) --- 19 years ago -

Damn...I sure am hugry now. 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

wow Kelmist that sounds super easy! Wonder what type of icing you use for the cake?? 

Kelmist --- 19 years ago -

There was a hint that said that you could even use ice cream as a frosting... nothing with chunks though. They say it's good if you whip it up good before you ice the cake. I would imagine that any icing would work though... Let us all know what you decide to do! 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

well... I found this! For the frosting, there are many options: frosting from a can, seven minute frosting, butter cream, sweetened whipped cream or even Cool Whip. Since it is going to be frozen, we want a frosting that will stand up to being frozen without cracking. My personal favorite frosting for ice cream cakes is Cool Whip. It's easy, tastes good and freezes well. Any type of whipped topping will do. Spread the whipped topping onto top and sides of cake. Make sure the topping or frosting is refrigerator temperature and not frozen. Using a long spatula, spread the frosting or topping evenly over the cake and decorate as desired. Running threads of chocolate syrup back and forth over the cake can be very pretty and you can get creative with nuts and even Oreos. Caramel looks very pretty, but it will begin to puddle on the cake if done too many hours in advance. Again, fruit and berries will be frozen and hard to eat, so I suggest not using them. Keep the entire cake in the freezer until about 15 to 30 minutes before serving. 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

Think i will use the cool whip icing! I usually make my own butter cream icing from scratch but this would be a lot easier!! 

Cioccolata --- 19 years ago -

And maybe share some of the ice cream cake with us ?? :p 

Kelmist --- 19 years ago -

I would go with Cool Whip too! That sounds really yummy. I might have to try a cake myself now that you've got me thinking about it...... 

~Melissa~ --- 19 years ago -

lol... O.k. I am thinking a yellow cake mix maybe a sponge cake. I thought about vanilla ice cream with bits of maybe like snicker bar. What combo would you guys do?? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Wilmington Underground